Presentation at Canadian Pain Society Winnipeg 2013 found only 23.7% of severe neuropathic pain victims responded to Canadian Pain Society drug protocols for neuropathic pain. It is time to look outside the box for treatment measures.
Neuropathic Pain Sig Meeting
Canadian Pain Society
Winnipeg, Canada May 2013
later published in:
Moulin, Dwight E., et al.
Long-term outcome of the management of chronic neuropathic pain: a prospective observational study.
The Journal of Pain 16.9 (2015): 852-861.
treatment was based on protocol worked out here:
Moulin, D. E., Clark, A. J., Gilron, I., Ware, M. A., Watson, C. P. N., Sessle, B. J., … & Velly, A. (2007).
Pharmacological management of chronic neuropathic pain–consensus statement and guidelines from the Canadian Pain Society.
Pain Research & Management: The Journal of the Canadian Pain Society, 12(1), 13-21.
Their protocol is pictured as such: – though later version uses marijuana early
Only 23.7% were controlled by these measures. An article in press also states this very succinctly:
[re Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS)] –
“The existing data from treatment trials conventional analgesics, anti-neuropathic pain medications or nerve blocks have been largely disappointing [3, 4]”
3. Rowbotham MC. Pharmacologic management of complex regional pain syndrome. The Clinical journal of pain 2006; 22: 425-9.
4. Cossins L, Okell RW, Cameron H, Simpson B, Poole HM, Goebel A. Treatment of complex regional pain syndrome in adults: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials published from June 2000 to February 2012. European journal of pain 2013; 17: 158-73.
“and much of the emphasis in treatment is on functional rehabilitation …. The limitations of existing treatments means that a substantial cohort of CRPS patients… is left with refractory, long-term severe pain causing significant disability.”
An example of infectiveness of oral treatments comes into light with a study on gabapentin, the jewel of neuropathic pain treatment, on neuropathic pain in 2002:
Pain. 2002 Oct;99(3):557-66.
Gabapentin in neuropathic pain syndromes: a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.
Serpell MG; Neuropathic pain study group
Though they talk glowingly about summations of certain findings, the overall pain was not statistically better than placebo after 6 weeks (the lack of stars at bottom). I have extended the graph to the bottom and it is obvious changes are not great.
To be fair however, there was a 20% subgroup that did get over 50% improvement though I cannot say if it would last..
Also it is common to take patients to 3600 mg/day now though how many can tolerate that I do not know.
The other Jewel was pregabalin. It failed to show longterm effectiveness in a recent trial of chronic sciatica pain – what 1/2 of neuropathic pain patients suffer from.
Sciatica Pain Is Different and Does NOT Respond Much to Pregabalin (Lyrica)
Much of the effectiveness of Tricylic antidepressants comes from a study where by frequent calls and support, subjects were worked up to 125 mg of amitriptyline for diabetic neuropathy pain. No study since has been able to get subjects past 25-75 mg and at that level, response is inadequate. I have a long-winded discussion about this here:
Below is the effectiveness of lower dose amitriptyline in various studies: A drop of 2 is considered CLINICALLY significant. However, I had a discussion with Dr. R. Dworkin, one of the heads of the US neuropathic pain group, about this clinically significant level and he contends if the drug is clinically safe and tolerable, then less effect is still important. – so try it and see.
Concerns raised re treatment guidelines:
- Valproic acid probably not as effective as other 4th line measures; Topical lidocaine maybe not as effective.
- (Raised by me) Neuropathic pain drugs do not work well on radiculopathy pains which constitute nearly 1/2 of chronic neuropathic pains.
- (My concerns) – fails to consider entrapments –
– tarsal tunnel syndrome considered by some an integral part of diabetic neuropathy requiring surgery – as per
Electrodiagnostically, Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome Rampant in Diabetics
Surgery For Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy – Another Option Not Available Here
Nerve Entrapment in Diabetic (DM) Peripheral Neuropathy – Surgery Helps Foot Ulcers and Charcot Foot Syndrome
– piriformis entrapment – in chronic back and post-laminectomy pain, division of piriformis was successful in 85% of cases in relieving pain:
Division of the pyriformis muscle for the treatment of sciatica. Postlaminectomy syndrome and osteoarthritis of the spine.
Arch Surg 1976;111:719 –722. abstract poor HTML from google cache
Various injections and physiotherapy techniques could be used but are vigorous
Enbrel Failure – So What Else Can You Do For Chronic Back Sciatica?
– Scalene and Pectoralis minor contributions to cervical/whiplash radiculopathy – a topic in its own
- Nerve Blocks regional and epidural are considerations. I feel midazolam epidural/intrathecal could be offered when epidurals wear off between steroid injections:
Epidurals are fraught with the need for subject to lie down for 20 minutes after injection with bad side down, and the issue the shot could get on the wrong side of epidural septum. The mineralcorticoid effects of the steroid are pro-inflammatory which could blunt response. I feel the day of steroid alone shots should be over and steroid plus entanercept shots should be done -with the original successful 25 mg – not like a recent negative pathetically-dosed 4 mg study used recently.
- The Canadian Pain Society also has documentation on interventional injections:
NERVE BLOCKS FOR NEUROPATHIC PAIN SUMMARY OF THE LITERATURE
At the conference, I bought up a series of options that could be potentially useful:
- Therapeutic B12 levels (around 1,200 ng/ml) – 2 weeks of B12 1000 ug/day, subcutaneously given by patient , for 14 days can bring levels up quickly to that level (not achievable for several month on oral meds). Shots are there maintained on need basis (1-7 days). As per findings here:
Chronic Back Pain Help – Forgotten B12 Injections and What Else Good For…
- Ketamine shots – have found 10 mg ketamine given twice or 3 times into deltoid muscle – separated by 15 minute each – could capture significant control of pain and mood. Depersonalization side effects could be avoided by terminating shots should subject start feeling”funny”. One subject had an episode of bladder frequency on 15 mg X 3 divided by 15 minutes each, but when retried 6 months later, has never had a problem with 10 mg X 2 (a dose she had originally been on and managed well on). However, still not a drug of people with bladder issues.
- A one shot IV version of ketamine – lidocaine is promoted by an Ottawa anesthesiologist, Dr. Ellen Thompson. It involves considerable sedation and I have not done it. I have persuaded Dr. Mike Lang of anesthesia to do it at Regina General Hospital for select patients:
- Treatments for Complex Regional Pain:
– IV biphosponates- despite a trial finding one infusion did not work, prior, and subsequent trials have found it useful in severe regional pains when given 3 times:
Pamidronate and Clodronate – hope for Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (aka CRPS) and Back Pain
Pamidronate Works Again – For Childhood Leg Pain – Complex Regional Pain
C0nfirmed Again – Biphosphonates Work In Complex Regional Pain–
One of the studies with Three consecutive day infusions of 1 mg/kg/day (= 80 – 90 mg for people around here…)
They found” On the 45th day after the beginning of the treatment, total disappearance of pain was obtained in 25 patients (86.2%) and functional improvement was obtained in 14 out of 20 patients (70%).”
Rheumatology (Oxford). 2001 Dec;40(12):1394-7.
Treatment of reflex sympathetic dystrophy with pamidronate: 29 cases.
Kubalek I, Fain O, Paries J, Kettaneh A, Thomas M.
- 5 Day Infusions: – mentioned the 5 day treatments to one anesthetist – his comment – “never going to happen”. It will take legislature to make it happen because the medical community will not spare the resources.
-IV Magnsium :
New Hope For Complex Regional Pain Syndrome I – 5 days Magnesium Infusions
No Hope Severe Neuropathic/CRPS Pain?- 4-5 Day IV Lidocaine to Rescue
– IV ketamine:
IV Ketamine – Pain Rescue For Refractory Pain Flareups – http://painmuse.org/?p=489 -mentions how some had daily infusions for 4 days – (suspect 5 would be better).
Recent review high-lighting prolong ketamine infusion advantage:
Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2013 May 23.(in press)
Prolonged ketamine infusion as a therapy for Complex Regional Pain Syndrome:Synergism with antagonism?
Pickering AE, McCabe CS.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23701138A good update review of IV treatments for chronic pain can be reviewed free here:Pain Physician. 2013 May-Jun;16(3):231-49.
Intravenous infusions in chronic pain management.
Kosharskyy B, Almonte W, Shaparin N, Pappagallo M, Smith H.
- Treatments for pains with paresthesias – even in Fibromyalgia, the addition of paresthesias brings up the possibility of Chronic Demyeliniating Inflammatory Neuropathy (CIDP) for which pulse steroids, immunoglobulin infusions , and plasmaphoresis could be helpful:
-Use included Dexamethasome 4 mg – 4 am, 4 lunch, 2 supper = 40 mg/day – for 4 days
Pulsed high-dose dexamethasone versus standard prednisolone treatment for chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (PREDICT study): a double-blind, randomised, controlled trial
Ivo N van Schaik MD a , Filip Eftimov MD a, Pieter A van Doorn MD c, Esther Brusse MD c, Leonard H van den Berg MD d, W Ludo van der Pol MD d, Catharina G Faber MD e, Joost CH van Oostrom MD f, Oscar JM Vogels MD g, Rob DM Hadden MD h, Bert U Kleine MD i, Anouk GW van Norden MD i, Jan JGM Verschuuren MD j, Marcel GW Dijkgraaf PhD b, Marinus Vermeulen MD a
The Lancet Neurology, Volume 9, Issue 3, Pages 245 – 253, March 2010
- Use IV blood plasma gamma globulin:
Caro, X. J., Winter, E. F., & Dumas, A. J. (2008).
A subset of fibromyalgia patients have findings suggestive of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy and appear to respond to IVIg.
Rheumatology, 47(2), 208-211.
“Fifteen FMS/CIDP subjects were subsequently treated with IVIg (400 mg/kg each day for 5 days). Pain (P=0.01), tenderness (P=0.001) and strength (P=0.04) improved significantly. Fatigue and stiffness trended towards improvement.”
- Injecting myofascial triggers – I often use 5% lidocaine to get longer lasting results but stay clear of spine – results are often much better when combined with ketamine shots.
- Massage related techniques – some people have never had their knots taken out and are like wood to start with – takes time
- Prolotherapy – Backs that tire out standing or sitting too long make one suspect that is an issue. I have been experimenting with dilute testosterone injection which are less painful.
- Facet injections – also difficult to get done here
- Pulsed Radiofrequency to nerve root ganglion – an audit found it helped maange 1/4 low back pain sciatica cases:
Pulsed Radiofrequency Treatment Adjacent to the Lumbar Dorsal Root Ganglion for the Management of Lumbosacral Radicular Syndrome: A Clinical Audit
Koen Van Boxem et al
Pain Medicine Volume 12, Issue 9, pages 1322–1330, September 2011
Not seen at all here.
- Physio techniques – Strength training has been shown to play a prominent place in chronic knee pains and is too big a topic to go into here.
- Methadone – because of its dual mode of action (NMDA block and opioid mu receptor effects), it is the king of painkillers. One of the palliative care doctors might be willing to be involved.
- Spinal and peripheral nerve stimulation – a possible 3 year wait if at all here.
A poster example :
Greene, M., & Sugar, R. (2009). Poster 273:
Resolution of Intractable Bilateral Neuropathic Lower Extremity Pain of Unclear Etiology: A Case Report.
PM&R, 1(9), S222.
– 75% reduction of undetermine pain in legs with spinal cord stimulation in this case
- Botox injections – significant relief reported in piriformis syndrome and selected cases of back pains.
- intradermal D5W injections – If one is careful, one can feel the nerves under the skin in painful areas as being tender – If you pucker the skin and inject above it ever cm or so with D5W superficial to nerve, the soreness will temporarily remit. Repeated injections can make it more lasting.
- HCG injections – recent investigations found this can help and reduce opioid consumption 20-100%
- IV pamidronate for chronic back pain – infusions can reduce pain but 40% or more in recent studies
- antibiotics for chronic back pains – oral clavulin or flouroquinolone for 100 days can potentially reduce pains 50% a year later
Comment – had a case late last week subsisting with pains about 8/10 – could barely touch her anywhere. Among widespread pains was shoulder buristis bilaterally limiting elevation arm to less than 90 degrees. Apparently she was blood tested and steroid tried briefly but then taken off because it stopped working. She had had ulcers when young and was not on any arthritis NSAID’s. She was so bad, I gave her 2 shots of ketamine 10 mg 15 minutes apart, then gradually worked out here piriformis on one side. She had severe pain down inner aspect right knee going into meidal shin of neuralgic intensity much like saphenous neuralgia:
I injected saphenous nerve at adductor tunnel and it gave dramatic relief of pain except a patch just above kneecap – making me think this was maybe more obturator nerve too.
I taught her functional release (counterstrain) for psoas and piriformis on other side – you put the muscle in a short painfree position for 90 seconds, and the muscle will temporarily forget it is in pain… I ran blood work for inflammatory issues and started her on a steroid pulse (40 mg dexamethasone/day in divided doses – note don’t use this dose on a diabetic). I considered getting in touch with Dr. Carmen Johnson – one of our palliative care doctors to use methadone. By the next morning her ESR came back as 42 and the pulse steroid was already lowering her pain levels. I referred her to a rheumatologist (No temporal arteritis symptoms so will have to wait) re Polymylagia Rheumatica. She will start on 20 mg/day Prednisone after the pulse. Given that the steroid effects seem to wane after the last use, I wonder if methotrexate (not favored by out rheumatologist) or etanercept should be added. A biphosphonate will be added once sure of stomach tolerance to steroids. Will need to check blood pressures and glucose levels. I imagine I will have to deal with here knees (restricted knee flexion and probable OA knees) – and multiple triggers – especially piriformi and subscapularis. B12 shots were taught for this lady.
I want people to realize there are always new options (heck, I have started 3 fairly severe back pain cases on 100 day antibiotics given a positive study on it use).
There however, needs to be the political will to make it happen. Given that every third household has significant chronic pain issues, it is an invisible tip of the iceberg. Our coping-training pain clinic in Saskatoon is closing down due to lack of funding; and our anesthetists have to impose on post operative care (much to the dislike of some staff) to do their blocks in Regina as there is no pain clinic here. Sadly, the same people who ignore this issue will have it slammed in their face – by old age where chronic pain can run rampant – and in if you get dementia, possibly cruely untreated. – So ironic. The medical community will not spare the resources necessary to make 5 day infusions or other advanced treatments possible. This needs to be addressed politically at election time.
Hey – I’m sure I missed plenty – did not tackle psychological treatments and so forth. Surely some people would have stories of what worked for them or their patients…